Which Mattress Toppers Are Best?

Adding an extra layer of cushioning can make your bed feel more comfortable and can also ease joint pressure. But which mattress covers are the best?

Dr. Holliday Bell recommends this organic option for people who want the firm support and the comfort of memory foam but do not want to use chemical. It has a removable cover and offers a range of firmness levels to accommodate the majority of sleepers.

1. Sleep Innovations Gel Memory Foam Topper

The topper is soft and comfortable for most people, but still provides support. Our testers loved the way it conformed to their bodies, giving support in all the right places. It can also be fitted to most mattresses however it can be a bit tricky to get the sheets on (read more about how to put on mattress toppers here). The thick layer of memory foam is machine washed and naturally antibacterial. It also features an upholstered cover made of sustainably-sourced bamboo and is hypoallergenic. It was a favorite of our panelists, however it's important to remember that it doesn't come with straps to help anchor the topper to your mattress and it's possible that it will move as you sleep.

The panelists who adored this topper also appreciated the fact that it eased back pain. It's an excellent choice for heavier sleepers who may discover that a topper with an average depth of three to four inches will ease pressure on a sensitive area such as hips and shoulders.

A two-inch layer of copper-infused memory foam absorbs heat and Which Mattress Toppers Are Best helps promote airflow for a cool night's sleep. Our test subject Jaclyn found the topper sufficient firmness to ease the pressure on her back, front, and side sleeping positions but not so firm that it felt uncomfortable. She also noticed that the back pain "pretty well disappeared over the course of the night." She was also impressed by the quietness of the topper, even when it's paired with a spring mattress. It also stops motion transfer, which makes it a good option for couples sharing a bed.

2. Coop Home Goods Retreat

Coop Home Goods mattress toppers have a plush pillow-like feel We were ecstatic to discover this model that can only be spot-cleaned. It's filled with the brand's crosscut microfiber and memory foam, so it's hypoallergenic and perfect for those looking to make a change to an existing soft mattress or revitalize a bed in a dorm room or guest room rental home. What makes this topper distinctive is the presence of five body-zones, each with different density zones, which allows it to be shaped and molded to your body's unique shape while still offering enough support.

The cover of this mattress protector is made from 100-percent brushed microfiber poly. It features a baffle box design that allows pockets to evenly distribute the fill. The topper also has four elastic straps at each corner that aid in keeping it in place on your mattress. The copper-infused memory absorbs heat from your body which keeps you cool during the night. It's topped off with 2" layer of ventilated memory for more breathability.

The Retreat is the ideal mattress topper for those who want a luxurious feel. When Strategist writer Louise tried it out, she reported that the topper quickly adapted to her body shape and supported her, making her feel well-supported and at ease. She typically overheats in bed, but the Retreat kept her cool and didn't move in the night. It comes in two firmness options, and back, side and stomach sleepers will be able to find it fits their preferences.

3. Nolah Beds Luxury Firm Memory Foam Topper

If you're looking for a mattress topper, there are plenty of options available. Some are designed to keep your body cool or regulate body temperature, while others offer some extra support or comfort. A mattress topper can be an ideal way to upgrade your current bed without spending a lot of money. A memory foam mattress topper is a good option for most sleepers, though should you prefer the bouncy feel of an innerspring mattress, consider a hybrid topper that blends latex with tiny nano-springs.

For those who sleep on their sides and backs, a firmer topper will better align your spine and reduce pressure on areas that are sensitive. Our test participant Julia was impressed by this four-inch topper by Tempur that is manufactured in the US and comes with a remarkable 120-night trial. She was happy with the added comfort and quality of sleep it provided. She did notice an off-gassing scent when she first opened the mattress, but this dissipated within one day.

This firmer option from Parachute offers memory foam that's shrunk and not as dense but still is comfortable. Lauren Levy, a Strategist contributor says it's "much cheaper than a down topper" and has similar marshmallow softness. She loved sleeping on it, but wouldn't recommend for front sleepers because her torso was smashed in the top.

A topper made from natural wool fleece is hypoallergenic and soft. It's not as breathable and can make you feel hot in the evening. A cotton topper is an option, since it's breathable and will keep you cool. Certain fabrics are infused with graphite or copper to keep your cool.

4. Sleep Innovations Gel Cooling Memory Foam Topper

This Puffy topper is a great budget option offering a soft, soft support that eases pressure at a low price. It comes in a variety in density and thickness options to help you find the perfect fit for your bed.

Strategist contributor Lauren Levy loved that this topper resembles down--it's "marshmallow soft" and has a baffle-box construction with pillow-y fiber-fill. It's hypoallergenic and comes with an easy-to-clean cover that helps you maintain the cleanliness in your bed.

The 2" layer of memory infused with copper is designed to promote airflow and help wick moisture away from your body during sleep. This lets you remain cool. Levy discovered that it was extremely supportive, even though it didn't bounce more than latex toppers. It's perfect for those who sleep on their backs, sides or stomachs, and also for those who suffer from chronic pain.

A 10-year guarantee and free shipping come standard. The topper is easy to clean; simply spot-clean and let it air dry. Be careful not to put it in the dryer or washer, as you'll void the warranty.

The Sleep Innovations Gel Cooling Memory Foam Topper provides a fantastic budget option for Which Mattress Toppers Are Best a dependable and soft super king size mattress topper. It is medium (5) firm and is suitable for most sleepers. However those who feel their mattress is too firm can benefit from this product. It also stops transfer of movement which is crucial for sleepers who are combination. Similar to the Coop Home Goods Retreat topper, this one provides relief from pressure for shoulder and neck pain. The only drawback to this topper is that it might not be as breathable as latex or polyfoam which is why it's not the ideal choice for sleepers who are hot.

5. Nolah Beds Luxury Plush Memory Foam Topper

The Nolah Beds Luxury Plush Memory Foam Topper is a fantastic option for side sleepers and back sleepers who are looking to soften the firmness of their mattress. This topper is also great for those suffering from chronic pain since it helps reduce pressure points. It's made in the USA using non-toxic materials and it's a great choice for those who sleep hot. It has a 2" layer of copper-infused foam which promotes breathability and also provides support. It also has a cover made of organic cotton that helps in regulating the moisture. Our tester Paige found that this mattress did a good job at preventing motion transfer and provided significant softness without sacrificing support. However, she noticed that the edges didn't completely cover her mattress If support for the edges is important for you, this may not be the right topper for you.

This topper is also easy to clean since it comes with an easily washable and removable cover. Additionally, it's hypoallergenic and antibacterial to ensure a healthy night's rest. It also has five body zones to support different parts of the mattress. It comes with a guarantee as well as a 120-night trial, which is longer than policies of other brands.

This is one of our cheaper alternatives however it doesn't compromise on quality. It's made from a combination of memory foam and natural latex, which gives it a luxuriously soft feel. It's a more dense layer of memory foam that provides additional comfort and promote a restful sleep. It's not the best choice for stomach sleepers as it sinks in too much. This can cause spinal misalignment. However, it is an excellent option for those who want an excellent night's sleep at an affordable price.